
A solid 3.5 rounded up... I loved the writing and I love a good all encompassing family story and IGYTS delivers. I liked the time hopping dual POVs between Jude and Noah. I did have a few niggles Noah's AWOL CSA application shouldn't have gone unnoticed. No confirmation letter? No rejection letter? Something's wrong! and how could Noah leave the lost connection ad, but never google Brian? does not make sense! And I had some more troubling issues Oscar, too much Oscar. The mother, grrrrr.... I would have gladly traded 30 pages of Oscar for a more thorough/less rushed treatment of Noah's story and how things with Brian worked out.